Planning to pay less tax does not make you a tax cheat
The problem with tax is many taxpayers do not have the first clue about their rights and are falling for the media frenzy the Chancellor is trying to whip up against tax avoidance.
George Osborne has made several speeches demonising tax cheats who are bleeding the country dry of billions of pounds each year.
In 2009, the tax gap – the margin between what was collected and what was estimated as owed- was £9 billion. Whether that’s an accurate figure or not is anyone’s guess.
But the fact is, tax avoidance is legal and everyone has a right to do their utmost to legally pay the least tax they can.
It’s not just an opinion. A succession of famous court cases has enshrined that right in law.
The first was Ayrshire Pullman Motor Services and Ritchie v Inland Revenue Commissioners (1929 14TC754).
Lord Clyde, who was presiding, famously said: No man in this country is under the smallest obligation, moral or other, so to arrange his legal relations to his business or to his property as to enable the Inland Revenue to put the largest possible shovel in to his stores.”
Every taxpayer has a right to honestly avoid tax
He went on to add: “ The Inland revenue is not slow to take every advantage which is open to it under the taxing statutes for depleting the taxpayer’s pocket. And the taxpayer is in like manner, entitled to be astute to prevent, so far as he honestly can the depletion of his means by the Revenue.”
This was supported in another celebrated tax case – Inland Revenue Commissioners v The Duke of Westminster (1936 19TC490) when Lord Tomlin reiterated the earlier case, saying: “Every man is entitled, if he can, to order his affairs so that the tax attaching under the appropriate Acts is less than it otherwise should be.”
To date, this general principle of tax law has not changed.
The Chancellor and anyone and everyone at HM Revenue and Customs can harangue tax cheats who avoid paying tax all they like in their media-go-round, but the law is the law. Tax avoidance is legal.
Tax evasion is most certainly not. Tax evasion is wrongly declaring income and tax due by deliberately falsifying or omitting financial records. Tax evasion is a crime.
The three key points of tax planning
Tax evaders are the real-world tax cheats. These are the individuals and corporations the Chancellor should really challenge.
Besides criminal law, the taxman has a powerful anti-evasion tool – The Ramsay Principle.
This also derives from a famous court case – WT Ramsay Ltd v Inland Revenue Commissioners (1981 STC 174).
Basically, the principle is that where tax is due and a taxpayer makes a transaction or series of transactions with no other purpose than evading tax, then the transactions should be ignored and the tax due at the start should be paid in full.
These three cases draw attention to the three key points of tax planning:
- Taxpayers have a right to pay as little tax as they can
- Honest avoidance within the rules is allowed
- Taxpayers who break the rules face criminal and financial penalties
The crucial point for a tax adviser is setting out a tax strategy within those parameters.